Chapter 4 - THE TWELFTH DOCTOR

The first time Dr. Adrian Sloane spoke to me, he'd asked whether I understood the difference between cleaning supplies and medication. He'd said it in front of three nurses, with a smile that encouraged them to laugh. I had been too new to the estate to answer him. Now I sat outside an interview room, remembering his expression and wondering how many people had mistaken politeness for goodness.
Evelyn Shaw arrived carrying a brown purse and wearing flat black shoes. She was older than I expected, with silver strands at her temples and the weary attention of someone accustomed to watching patients breathe. Detective Quinn introduced us without revealing what either of us had said privately.
Evelyn reached for my hand. “I'm sorry they blamed you,” she said.
“I was lucky there was a camera.”
“No,” she replied. “A camera caught one act. It didn't create your courage.”
We were interviewed separately. I learned later, through my attorney, that Evelyn had documented discrepancies in Matteo's treatment charts weeks before Carlo accused me. A note supposedly written by Evelyn said Matteo had refused further investigations. Yet Evelyn had been attending a different patient that day, and her agency's shift records could show it.
At a preliminary court hearing concerning access to Matteo's records, Sloane's attorney argued that the irregularity was an administrative mistake. That was possible. Quinn insisted that nobody treat a discrepancy as proof of intentional harm without corroboration. But the paper trail kept growing.
The hospital's pharmacy team found orders in Matteo's file that had been entered through a provider account at odd hours. His independent specialists reviewed his medications and decided to suspend several nonessential preparations while monitoring him. The toxicology work remained under way. Carlo's tea had been seized, but identifying what might have been given to Matteo over weeks required more than one cup.
Meanwhile, Vane filed an emergency petition claiming Matteo's decisions were impaired by his medical condition and by the influence of household employees. Reading those words made my face grow hot. I'd spent months scrubbing floors while lawyers arranged papers no one had thought to show the man they supposedly protected.
At the hearing, Matteo appeared by secure video from the hospital. He was weak, but he answered the judge's questions clearly. He named the date, described the disputed amendments, and asked for an independent representative to review his interests. His physician told the court there was no basis for equating his current physical weakness with a blanket inability to make decisions.
The judge declined to give Vane the sweeping emergency control he sought. The court instead required notice before disputed property transfers and scheduled further review. It wasn't a total victory. But that evening Matteo slept without wondering whether someone could move his world with a forged signature while he was unconscious.
When I visited, he had the court order on his blanket. “My father would have said we shouldn't have needed a judge to remind us of what belongs to whom.”
“Would he have been right?” I asked.
“Usually. Not always.”
Matteo told me about his father, Salvatore, who had built warehouses along the river and later created a housing trust when a neighborhood was cleared to make room for the docks. He'd done harm and then attempted to repair some of it. The blue ledger listed families whose rights remained unresolved. To Carlo the properties represented land. To Matteo, at least now, they represented promises his father had never fully kept.
“You knew those promises existed,” I said.
“Yes.”
“Then why were they sitting in a locked cabinet?”
He looked at me for a long time. “Because it was easier to tell myself paperwork meant somebody else was handling them.”
I appreciated the admission, though it made me sad. Powerful men loved to describe failures as things that happened somewhere beneath them, where their eyes didn't go.
After my visit, Enzo offered to drive me back. I agreed only when the support counselor confirmed the trip had been arranged safely. Outside the hospital it was raining, a fine autumn rain that turned streetlights into blurred yellow circles.
“Yellow,” I said before I could stop myself.
Enzo glanced over. “What?”
“Matteo said the lights looked yellow. I'm still frightened every time I see that color.”
“Do you think he'll recover?”
“I hope so. But I'm not his doctor.”
Enzo gripped the steering wheel. “I've been watching that man rule the family since I was a boy. Hearing him ask permission to sit up…” He shook his head. “I didn't know how to stand it.”
“You don't have to turn fear into orders,” I told him.
“I know.”
He stopped at a red light. “I thought if I made you confess, Carlo would stop shouting. I hadn't even asked myself what confession I wanted.”
“That kind of thing isn't just embarrassing. It teaches everyone who's watching that the next person to raise a problem might be punished.”
“I'll make a statement to the staff tomorrow.”
“Good. Let them know it comes with a reporting procedure that doesn't run through Carlo or Vane.”
For the first time, Enzo smiled. “You always have another condition.”
“That's what happens when you start listening to someone who cleans your floors.”
The next morning, a message came from Evelyn. She'd found an old paper copy of a medication review she had been told was destroyed. Her agency's rules required her to provide it to investigators, not to me. She had done so. The review recorded a concern about an unidentified daily beverage brought from outside the clinical team. It bore Sloane's electronic sign-off, but no follow-up note.
There was more troubling news: Gareth Pike, the maintenance contractor, had vanished from his registered address. A neighbor said he'd left with a duffel bag three days earlier. Detectives were tracing financial transactions associated with his firm, while the estate's accountants identified an invoice approved by a senior manager under a category called discreet estate corrections.
“Discreet corrections?” I repeated when Quinn informed me of the wording. “That's not a real service.”
“It might refer to ordinary confidentiality work,” she cautioned. “It could also conceal something else. We need the records.”
That afternoon an unmarked envelope arrived at the support agency, but this time the receptionist recognized the name on its return address. It was from Harold Vane's office, served through a courier with tracking details. Inside was a formal notice alleging that I had stolen confidential estate documents and demanding that I return them immediately.
I called my lawyer. “I don't have their documents.”
“Then don't reply by yourself,” she said. “We'll respond formally.”
The notice attached a photograph. It showed me carrying a small blue book down the service stairs. The image was taken the week before Matteo's collapse. My breath caught when I recognized the cover.
It wasn't the blue ledger. It was my grandmother's botanical journal, which I'd taken home after Carlo looked through it.
They'd photographed me and labeled the book as stolen property.
My attorney examined the image and shook her head. “They're constructing a story. We can challenge the claim with the original journal and your account.”
I pressed my hand over my eyes. “Will it ever stop?”
“I can't promise when. But you don't have to face each piece alone.”
That night, Detective Quinn called with a development she said was verified but not yet public. The original hospital bank records showed a payment from a Costa-associated consulting company into a firm linked to Sloane. The money had arrived the day before Matteo's most severe deterioration.
“Does that mean they paid him to hurt Matteo?” I asked.
“Not by itself. We need a legitimate explanation, or evidence that the explanation is false.”
Before hanging up, she added, “We found another transaction. A significant transfer to an account in the name of a deceased Costa employee.”
“Who?”
“Elias Rourke. He was the previous security supervisor. His death was recorded five years ago.”
I sat motionless. I knew that name. The portrait of Elias Rourke still hung in the security office, beside a photograph of Matteo's father.
Someone was using the dead man's identity to move money.
One afternoon, Keller invited me to attend a short patient-safety discussion with Matteo's permission. The clinicians talked about documentation, medication reconciliation, and the importance of reporting concerns without ridicule. I expected to be treated like a curiosity. Instead the senior nurse asked which question I'd found hardest to ask. “Whether somebody had checked the tea,” I answered. She wrote it on the whiteboard. “That's a useful question,” she said. “You don't need to identify a toxin to report an unusual pattern.” I left with a sharper understanding of what my grandmother had taught me. Observation mattered, but diagnosis belonged to trained professionals. I could help by telling the truth about what I had seen, not by pretending I had solved an entire medical mystery from an old journal.
May you like
And for the first time I began to wonder whether Carlo's plan had started long before Matteo fell ill.
================================================