stream

Chapter 7 - HELEN TAKES THE STAND

The courthouse steps were wet the morning Helen DeLuca went to testify. A gust of wind sent fallen leaves scraping along the sidewalk, and television crews had begun gathering near the front entrance. They wanted a photograph of the famous DeLuca family. They wanted Caroline looking humiliated, Vincent looking dangerous, Helen looking frail.

They didn't get the last one.

Helen wore a charcoal jacket with pearl buttons and her favorite blue scarf. She had asked her physical therapist to adjust the position of her wheelchair cushion so she could sit comfortably through a long hearing. She carried a narrow binder on her lap.

"Should I push?" I asked.

"No, thank you. The ramp is manageable," she said. "You may take my bag. It's heavy with all the things people insist I couldn't possibly understand."

I held the bag while she propelled herself toward the accessible entrance. Vincent walked on her other side, resisting what I could see was a powerful desire to clear the entire staircase of reporters by sheer force of will.

"Mr. DeLuca! Is your mother suing your fiancée?"

"Did Caroline Mercer steal from your family?"

"Are you calling off the wedding?"

Vincent stopped only long enough to say, "My engagement is over. The legal questions belong in court, and my mother speaks for herself."

Then Helen added, "And I wish someone would ask about the people Bluebird House was built to serve. They are the ones being forgotten."

Inside, a court officer directed us to a quiet waiting room. I was scheduled to testify about what happened at the mansion and what I personally saw, not about the complicated property transactions. Miriam had prepared me by practicing the hardest sentence in the world: I don't know.

"A witness is not more useful because she guesses," Miriam told me. "Say what you know, and stop there."

In the courtroom, Caroline sat beside Edgar Voss, whose silver hair made him look distinguished until he began glaring at Helen. Julian Cross occupied the seat behind their lawyers, a perfectly pressed handkerchief folded in his breast pocket. Mark Mercer sat on a different bench, avoiding his wife's eyes.

The judge explained that this hearing concerned interim relief. Nobody was being convicted of a crime that day. The question was whether the court should temporarily stop the disputed transfer while the case proceeded.

Miriam began with the recorded deed, the suspicious signatures, and the Northgate referral. She then called Helen.

A courtroom staff member arranged the witness area so Helen could remain in her wheelchair. She took the oath in a clear voice.

"Mrs. DeLuca," Miriam asked, "did you consent to move to Northgate Residential Care?"

"No."

"Did you authorize Caroline Mercer or Julian Cross to make that decision for you?"

"No."

"Have you ever been told by a physician that you cannot manage your own property decisions?"

"No. I have a spinal cord injury. It affects my legs. It does not turn my brain into somebody else's property."

A quiet rustle moved through the courtroom.

Miriam waited. "What is Bluebird House to you?"

Helen's hands rested on the wheels of her chair. She looked toward the judge, not Vincent.

"It was where my husband and I took people who had nowhere safe to go. We weren't heroes. We had money and a building. Other people had courage and needed a roof. My husband promised the property would be protected for that purpose. I've been asking for an accounting because I want to know whether that promise was kept."

"Were you informed of the transfer shown in the disputed deed?"

"No. And I did not sign the consent attached to it."

Caroline's attorney stood for cross-examination. He asked whether Helen sometimes relied on caregivers for medication reminders, shopping, and transportation.

"Yes," she said.

"Would you agree that some daily decisions require assistance?"

"Of course. Needing help with an activity doesn't mean someone else gets to choose how my life is spent."

He asked whether she remembered every meeting she had attended nine years earlier.

"No," she replied. "Do you?"

A few people smiled. The judge called for order, though I thought I saw a hint of amusement in her expression.

The attorney produced a page bearing Helen's alleged signature and asked whether she could absolutely rule out signing it during a busy period.

Helen studied it. "I can tell you I did not agree to a sale. And I can tell you this signature is not mine. The examiner can tell you more about how the mark got onto the page."

It was a careful answer, and it left no room for the lawyer to portray her as confused.

Next came my testimony. My shoulder was healing, but the memory of the broken cabinet made my hands cold. I told the court about Caroline packing Helen's belongings, Helen refusing, my attempt to call Vincent, and the shove against the glass. I described the wheelchair tipping at dinner and Vincent catching his mother's shoulders.

"Did you see Caroline sign the disputed deed?" the opposing lawyer asked.

"No."

"Did you see her speak to anyone at Northgate?"

"No."

"So you can't know why the trip was arranged?"

"I can tell you Mrs. DeLuca said she didn't want to go. I can tell you Caroline ordered the suitcases packed anyway. I can't tell you what was in Caroline's mind."

He looked disappointed. I felt strangely proud.

Mark testified about the transport contract, admitting that he had failed to verify Helen's wishes. His voice shook when he acknowledged that the route instructions directed him to use a side entrance. Caroline stared at the floor.

Then Miriam presented Ruth Kaplan, who identified the archived correspondence and explained the sudden removal of records from Bluebird House. She did not exaggerate. She said what she had copied, when she had copied it, and who had ordered her dismissal.

Julian's lawyer argued that the development agreement was legitimate and any date errors resulted from clerical processing. The court was not asked to decide that issue finally. But when the judge asked Julian's attorney why the consent page carried the signature of a deceased witness, he offered no immediate explanation.

At the recess, I stood in the hallway, breathing slowly. Vincent approached with two paper cups of water.

"You did well," he said.

"I answered what they asked."

"You told them no when you didn't know. That was important."

I accepted the water. "I used to think saying 'I don't know' made me look stupid."

"I built half my life around pretending I knew more than I did," he said. "It caused plenty of damage."

We stood near a tall window overlooking the courtyard. For a moment the courtroom noise disappeared, leaving only the distant rumble of traffic.

"When this is over," Vincent said, "I hope you'll tell me if the house still feels like a place you can work. I don't want you staying because you feel indebted."

"I know. I'm thinking about what comes next."

"Whatever it is, it should be yours."

His gaze stayed with mine a little longer than necessary. I felt warmth climb into my face, then looked away. He didn't press.

Before the judge returned, I noticed Caroline sitting alone at the defense table while her attorneys whispered by the door. She caught my eye and opened her mouth, then looked away. I wondered whether she was thinking about the night of the engagement or only about what it had cost her. I couldn't know, and I no longer felt compelled to solve her feelings for her.

Ruth leaned toward me. "Your mother would have liked how you answered them."

"I almost fainted before they called my name," I admitted.

"Courage isn't a temperature that stays steady," she said. "It's what you do while your hands are cold."

I looked across the room. Helen was reading the next page of her binder with the seriousness of a woman preparing for a book-club debate. Vincent waited beside her instead of taking the pages away. Whatever happened in court, that small change in their relationship was real.

When court resumed, the judge issued a temporary order restricting transfer or encumbrance of the disputed Bluebird House interest, requiring preservation of relevant business and medical-placement records, and setting further proceedings. She made clear that the order was not a final determination of fraud or liability.

Helen reached for my hand under the table.

"It's a beginning," she whispered.

Outside, Caroline stood beside her father while reporters called questions. Julian hurried toward a waiting car. Vincent watched him leave, but did not follow. I knew that, once, he might have settled matters with intimidation. Now he had chosen something slower and far more difficult: leaving witnesses free to speak and records free to be examined.

In the car, Daniel handed Miriam a message from Detective O'Brien. The accountant who had died in the old fire, Thomas Reed, had left behind a daughter. She was alive and willing to discuss his records.

Her name was Grace Reed.

She had one request before meeting the DeLucas: Vincent must bring a photograph of his father, taken in the week before Joseph died.

Helen frowned. "Why a photograph?"

Miriam read the rest of the message aloud.

"Because Grace says her father received a visit from a man pretending to be Joseph DeLuca after Joseph's funeral."

Vincent looked sharply at her.

"Someone was impersonating my father?"

Nobody in the car answered.

May you like

The temporary court order had protected Bluebird House for now.

But the question of who had been wearing Joseph DeLuca's name was only beginning.

Related Stories

Other posts